How we are marked

download (4)

Seem I had such a great response to ‘Can I do this’ blog I thought I would share another great concern of mine and that is how we are marked.  Have you ever had that excited yet scared emotion when you hear results have been released?  Only to find your marked assignment is a big let down.  You have worked your butt off and you checked it numerous times against the rubric how could you possibly have such a crap mark?  Not to mention a fellow student who posted on face book two days before the assignment was due that they were only just starting, now she just posted that she got 98% !!!!

I found it interesting the other week when I read a lecturer’s comments on how we are marked.  They stated that a marker only has half an hour to mark each assignment and to ensure all markers are consistent an essay is randomly plucked out and all markers mark and then compare marks.  As long as the % of difference is low the markers are deemed consistent.  I am sure this is a system that has more than likely been used for some time however I have to ask how fair is this system?  Have you ever asked for a re-mark or wanted to ask for one?  I have and I was correct in doing so as my mark increased.   This was a good indication to me that I had fair grounds for requesting the re-mark.  I know of another student who also asked for a re-mark and was awarded an extra 10 points to her original mark !  The remarks which came through with her amended results was that the marker was having a bad day!  Seriously?

I know from my own personal experiences the sacrifices I make and the hours I put into every assignment and to have someone limited to half an hour to mark what takes well over the recommended study time to complete does seem a little unfair.   What erks me even more is the comments that are attached to assignments ( or the lack of).  There is nothing more disheartening than having a marked assignment returned full of negative comments.  I was lucky enough to do a course last semester where the marker provided very positive comments and no, my assignment was not of HD standard but the comments made me feel like I had put in a great effort and with a little tweaking I could reach the HD standard.

It is very disheartening to think that whether we receive a degree largely depends on how well we write an essay, express our creativeness or interpret a rubric (that may not always be relative to what one has learned throughout the course or difficult to interpret).  The fact that we are awarded only 1% for practical placement makes it appear that the marks awarded are unbalanced. Who is to say that ‘Johnny’ is a better teacher than ‘ Paul’ because he has achieved HDs for all of his assignments?  Yet he has no life experience, no children and finds it very difficult to teach or engage a room full of nine year olds.

These are just my opinions and I would love to hear if you agree or disagree.  I know one thing for sure, I want to encourage my future students to reach for the stars and I will be encouraging this by being a fair marker who also considers the little things such as the effort that was put in by the student.  Making a point of marking and returning their marked work in an appropriate time frame and most importantly only ever providing positive feedback (no red pens 🙂 ).

Cheers Leesa

images (6)

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “How we are marked

  1. I agree wholeheartedly in what you are saying. I worked very hard with the 1st assignment in ICT checking and rechecking my work against the rubric, only to find that it was not interesting enough, or I happen to mention a school name (by the way it was an example not relevant to the assignment), but was marked severely for it. I cannot see why in one assignment my marks were smashed and in another subject I get HD’s and remarks were that I have problems with my essay writing and sentence structure??
    It really baffles me….

  2. I agree with both Lessa and Lynns comments. To be told you are not creative enough, or poor sentence structure. Does all this writing make us good teachers? Are we actually learning what we need to?

  3. I had a similar issue as Lynn did, losing points for naming the school even though it was a fictitious name. I contacted the right person and my mark was amended. Apparently I also lack creativity. I thought I was very creative with my artifact!!

  4. Pingback: Assignment 1 Reflection | EDC3100 ICT learning journey

  5. Pingback: The education of education | Jasmine Smits

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: